For numerous girls, the phrase “menopause” is related to the phrase “low estrogen.” That is the narrative many have been informed, the reason provided when sizzling flashes strike, sleep turns into elusive or moods swing unpredictably. Typical drugs largely operates on this premise, with hormone alternative remedy (HRT) incessantly prescribed to replenish what’s believed to be misplaced — estrogen.
However what if this long-accepted understanding of menopause is not the whole image? Analysis is more and more questioning the singular concentrate on estrogen deficiency, suggesting as an alternative a extra nuanced actuality. Research point out that estrogen ranges in menopausal girls aren’t plummeting throughout the board. Actually, ranges in sure tissues, corresponding to physique fats, will be far greater than circulating blood ranges counsel.
This challenges the belief that merely changing “misplaced” estrogen by means of HRT is an acceptable answer. Certainly, boosting estrogen additional, when it is already considerable in tissues, might deepen the imbalance. It is necessary to grasp what’s actually taking place with hormones throughout menopause, and why a extra knowledgeable perspective might change the way you method your individual well being journey.
HRT Use Linked to A lot Increased Estrogen Ranges in Fats Tissue
A 2024 examine revealed in The Journal of Medical Endocrinology & Metabolism sought to grasp how HRT impacts intercourse hormones in postmenopausal girls.1 Researchers had been notably desirous about analyzing hormone concentrations not simply within the bloodstream but additionally immediately inside adipose tissue, generally referred to as physique fats.
• The examine concerned postmenopausal girls with and with out HRT — This analysis concerned 63 postmenopausal girls — 50 utilizing oral HRT and 13 not utilizing it. Fats and blood samples had been collected throughout belly surgical procedure for noncancerous gynecologic circumstances, and the 2 teams had been in contrast at a single cut-off date.
Scientists measured concentrations of key intercourse hormones like estrone, estradiol, progesterone, and testosterone, in each their subcutaneous fats (fats slightly below the pores and skin) and visceral fats (deeper belly fats), in addition to of their blood serum. The findings indicated that HRT customers had markedly greater estrogen ranges not solely of their blood but additionally inside their fats tissue, together with completely different androgen concentrations.
• HRT customers had a lot greater estrogen inside fats — Ladies utilizing HRT had fourfold to sevenfold greater concentrations of two main estrogens, estrone and estradiol, inside each subcutaneous and visceral fats, in comparison with girls not on HRT.
Whereas estrogen was far greater in fats, testosterone, an androgen hormone, was about 30% decrease in visceral fats within the HRT group in comparison with the non-HRT group. Though whole testosterone ranges within the blood remained comparable between each teams, the quantity of freely circulating testosterone within the blood was decrease within the HRT customers.
Determine 1. Postmenopausal girls utilizing HRT had 4 to seven instances extra estrone and estradiol of their fats tissue than nonusers, and about 30% much less testosterone in visceral fats.
• Estrogen-to-androgen ratios had been far greater in fats tissues with HRT — Additional, the researchers calculated the ratios of estrogens to androgens inside fats tissue, and the outcomes had been putting. In girls utilizing HRT, these estrogen-to-androgen ratios had been between 9 and 12 instances greater in subcutaneous fats and 4 to 6 instances greater in visceral fats when in comparison with girls not utilizing HRT.
• HRT shifted hormone steadiness to favor estrogen regionally in fats — This shift towards a better estrogen-to-androgen steadiness inside fats tissue means that HRT creates a hormonal surroundings in fats that is closely skewed towards estrogen relative to androgens. Much more granularly, the examine famous that in visceral fats, estrogen-to-androgen ratios rose because the estradiol dose within the HRT routine elevated.
Determine 2. In contrast with nonusers, girls on HRT had estrogen-to-androgen ratios 9 to 12 instances greater in subcutaneous fats and 4 to six instances greater in visceral fats.
These findings level towards a major affect of HRT on what’s known as intracrine intercourse steroid metabolism inside adipose tissue. Intracrine metabolism refers to hormone manufacturing and motion throughout the cells and tissues themselves, relatively than solely counting on hormones circulating within the bloodstream.
The examine’s outcomes, notably the constantly excessive ratio of estrogen in fats tissue in comparison with serum even in HRT customers, counsel that HRT might considerably affect how fats tissue processes and metabolizes intercourse hormones regionally.
It is price retaining the featured examine’s design in thoughts. This was a cross-sectional comparability of fifty HRT customers and solely 13 nonusers, so it exhibits variations between teams relatively than modifications in the identical girls over time. Furthermore, the authors be aware that a few of their analyses relied on small samples.
In addition they steered that the native modifications they noticed could possibly be concerned in HRT’s identified tendency to restrict menopause-related stomach fats acquire — whereas additionally noting that the markedly excessive estrone ranges within the fats tissue of HRT customers increase questions on total estrogen publicity, together with in relation to estrogen-dependent cancers of the breast and endometrium.
The Case That Menopause Entails Estrogen Dominance, Not Deficiency
Georgi Dinkov, a revered skilled in metabolic well being, offered commentary on The Journal of Medical Endocrinology & Metabolism examine in a February 2025 submit on his weblog, shifting the main focus from estrogen deficiency to estrogen dominance in menopause.2 Dinkov’s evaluation emphasizes that taking a look at hormone ratios, relatively than simply absolute ranges, paints a really completely different image of the hormonal panorama throughout and after menopause.
• Dinkov detailed the hormone ranges in girls not utilizing HRT (the management group) — Opposite to the frequent perception that menopausal girls are estrogen-deficient, Dinkov factors out that absolutely the ranges of key estrogens — estrone, estradiol, and estrone sulfate — measured in these girls weren’t truly low. Actually, their estrogen ranges had been throughout the regular laboratory reference ranges. He additionally famous that their blood progesterone sat very near the decrease restrict of its regular vary.
• He argues menopause shouldn’t be seen as an estrogen-deficient state — This commentary challenges the foundational concept that menopause is basically a situation of estrogen shortage. Additional, in his view, hormonal steadiness is not simply concerning the amount of particular person hormones, however about their ratios to 1 one other. Within the case of feminine hormones, the progesterone-to-estrogen ratio is a key indicator of endocrine well being.
• He provides that this ratio ought to ideally be fairly excessive, within the vary of 200 to 500 — Dinkov considers a ratio under 100 indicative of estrogen dominance, and notes that ratios this low have been noticed in nearly all circumstances of estrogen receptor-positive breast most cancers.3
Upon calculating the progesterone-to-estrogen ratio from the info of the non-HRT group within the examine, he concluded that these “wholesome” menopausal girls already exhibited vital estrogen dominance. In blood serum, the progesterone-to-estrogen ratio was a mere 16. In subcutaneous fats, it was round 20, and in visceral fats, roughly 38.
• Such low ratios could be regarding in premenopausal girls — By Dinkov’s thresholds, all of those ratios fall effectively under the optimum vary and squarely throughout the zone of estrogen dominance. Dinkov argues that if these girls had been premenopausal and introduced with such low progesterone-to-estrogen ratios, it might set off alarm bells, doubtless resulting in a referral to an endocrine specialist and remedy geared toward elevating progesterone exercise.
Determine 3. By Georgi Dinkov’s calculations, progesterone-to-estrogen ratios in girls not utilizing HRT had been 16 in blood, about 20 in subcutaneous fats and about 38 in visceral fats, all under his threshold of 100.
Dinkov concludes that the widespread use of estrogenic HRT wants severe reconsideration in mild of those findings. If menopausal girls already have a tendency towards estrogen dominance — even with out HRT — then additional rising estrogen ranges with HRT might exacerbate this imbalance, worsening well being relatively than enhancing it.
Estrogen’s Double-Edged Sword — Important but Problematic
A 2018 essential assessment revealed in Biomedicine & Pharmacotherapy highlights the complicated function of estrogen in human well being.4 Estrogen has a twin nature that is each essential for quite a few bodily features and, paradoxically, linked to illness when its ranges are out of steadiness. Actually, estrogen is excess of only a intercourse hormone; it is a key participant in total well being and well-being, with results that span far past replica.
• Estrogen helps essential physique methods however can also be disease-linked — Estrogen is concerned in sustaining glucose and lipid steadiness, supporting a sturdy immune system, guaranteeing bone power, selling cardiovascular well being, and facilitating wholesome mind perform. Nonetheless, the exact same estrogen can also be implicated in quite a few ailments, starting from infections and autoimmune issues to metabolic disturbances and degenerative circumstances.
• Estrogen is a “essential evil” — This contradictory nature of estrogen — each life-supporting and dangerous — is what the paper calls its “essential evil” side. The purpose is that each too little and an excessive amount of estrogen have been linked to persistent and acute well being issues. Individually from this assessment, the bioenergetic view of well being holds that extra estrogen can also increase calcium ranges inside cells and impair mitochondrial perform.
• Environmental chemical substances might contribute to estrogen dominance — The paper factors out that elevated publicity to inflammatory brokers and endocrine-disrupting chemical substances (EDCs) in your every day surroundings can enhance estrogen ranges, or mimic estrogen’s results, fueling estrogen dominance.
Determine 4. Estrogen helps glucose and lipid steadiness, immunity, bone, coronary heart, and mind well being, however when out of steadiness it has been linked to a variety of ailments.
In keeping with the featured assessment, this extra estrogen, or estrogen-like exercise, can drive an overexpression of estrogen receptors, which the authors hyperlink to tissue hurt, autoimmune ailments, and cancers.
• Rising charges of hormone-related ailments level to imbalance — The authors counsel that the rising charges of circumstances like polycystic ovarian syndrome (PCOS), infertility, breast most cancers, ovarian most cancers, and gynecomastia (breast tissue in males) are a sign that estrogen ranges have gotten more and more imbalanced within the inhabitants.
Additional, as a result of estrogen interacts intricately with many different hormones, enzymes, and metabolic pathways, merely manipulating estrogen ranges immediately — for instance, with medication that block estrogen manufacturing or estrogen receptors — is dangerous and might have unintended penalties, and the authors be aware that HRT isn’t freed from uncomfortable side effects both.
The researchers advocate sensible dietary decisions and consciously minimizing publicity to dangerous chemical substances with a view to naturally restore and preserve estrogen steadiness.
Taking Management of Your Estrogen Stability
Managing menopause is much less a couple of easy estrogen “top-up” and extra about reaching a balanced hormonal surroundings in your physique. Given the rising view that estrogen dominance, not deficiency, could also be a key challenge for a lot of, a strategic method is important.
You’ve vital energy to affect your hormone steadiness by means of on a regular basis decisions, which can scale back your reliance on standard estrogen-based therapies — although any change to a prescribed hormone remedy needs to be made together with your physician. Listed here are a number of concrete steps you may take proper now to naturally help wholesome estrogen ranges and counter estrogen dominance.
1. Know your prolactin stage — Many individuals imagine they’re low in estrogen resulting from bloodwork, when they might even have a lot greater ranges in tissues corresponding to physique fats. It’s because serum estrogen ranges might not be consultant of estrogen that is saved in tissues.
Estrogen will be low in plasma however excessive in tissues. That mentioned, prolactin ranges might supply a helpful clue about estrogen exercise, as estrogen immediately stimulates your pituitary gland to supply prolactin. Prolactin can also be influenced by different elements, together with sure drugs, stress, and thyroid perform, so it’s an oblique marker relatively than a direct measure of estrogen.
When prolactin ranges are elevated, it might sign elevated estrogen receptor activation, whether or not out of your physique’s personal estrogen manufacturing or environmental exposures to EDCs in microplastics and different pollution. This relationship is especially vital when mixed with low thyroid perform, making prolactin a probably helpful marker for figuring out hormonal imbalance. However earlier than deciding on something, discuss to your well being care supplier about whether or not this testing is acceptable for you.
2. Get rid of seed oils in your food regimen — Processed meals generally comprise seed oils, wealthy in polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFs) like linoleic acid, which can have estrogen-like results, contributing to estrogen dominance. Because of this, PUFs might disrupt hormonal steadiness and mitochondrial perform. Preserve your LA consumption between 2 and 5 grams per day. The Meals Buddy, a part of upcoming PAX app, may also help you observe how a lot LA is in your meals.
3. Turn out to be a aware client of on a regular basis merchandise — Many on a regular basis merchandise comprise estrogen-mimicking compounds, together with xenoestrogens. These sneaky EDCs are frequent in microplastics, private care merchandise, and family cleaners.
To reduce your publicity, select pure and natural private care merchandise, scrutinizing labels for parabens and phthalates. Swap out standard cleaners for pure, unhazardous choices — vinegar and baking soda are secure, easy alternate options.
Importantly, scale back your plastic use, notably for meals and drinks. Favor glass and stainless-steel, and do not warmth meals in plastic, as warmth accelerates the leaching of those estrogenic chemical substances into your meals. Filter your faucet water to take away microplastics and should you purchase bottled water, select glass.
In case you have exhausting faucet water, boiling it might additionally assist. In a 2024 laboratory examine, boiling exhausting faucet water for 5 minutes eliminated not less than 80% of the added nano- and microplastics, which grew to become trapped within the mineral scale that fashioned — so, pour the water by means of a high-quality filter, corresponding to a stainless-steel tea strainer, to take away that scale earlier than ingesting.5
4. Rethink estrogen-based therapies and contraceptives — Rigorously consider your use of estrogens in HRT and contraception drugs, as they’ll contribute to estrogen dominance. Discuss together with your physician earlier than altering or stopping any prescribed hormone remedy or contraceptive.
Discover therapies and contraceptive strategies that prioritize your physique’s pure hormonal equilibrium. Keep in mind, bioidentical estrogen, whereas usually marketed as pure, remains to be an exterior estrogen supply that contributes to your estrogen load.
5. Think about pure progesterone to counter estrogen — For these reaching perimenopause and menopause, pure progesterone is a very useful consideration to debate with a doctor, since it’s a prescription hormone. Progesterone acts as a pure antagonist to estrogen, serving to to steadiness its results. Given the tendency towards estrogen dominance, incorporating pure progesterone might assist restore a extra balanced hormonal ratio.
Incessantly Requested Questions About Estrogen Stability in Menopause
Q: Is menopause actually nearly low estrogen?
A: Whereas standard knowledge says menopause is because of estrogen deficiency, analysis and skilled commentary counsel that estrogen ranges aren’t all the time low and that many menopausal girls may very well expertise estrogen dominance, which means they’ve an excessive amount of estrogen relative to progesterone.
A 2018 assessment additionally describes how on a regular basis publicity to inflammatory brokers and estrogen-mimicking chemical substances can push estrogen exercise greater, fueling estrogen dominance.6 This shifts the main focus from merely changing estrogen to reaching total hormonal steadiness.
Q: If estrogen is not all the time low, why is HRT so usually prescribed?
A: Many individuals imagine they’re low in estrogen resulting from bloodwork, when they might even have a lot greater ranges in tissues corresponding to physique fats. It’s because estrogen will be low in plasma however excessive in tissues. Critics corresponding to Dinkov argue that standard HRT is usually prescribed based mostly on an incomplete image of estrogen deficiency.
Nonetheless, a 2024 examine discovered that ladies utilizing HRT had a lot greater estrogen ranges in each their blood and their fats tissue than nonusers,7 which Dinkov argues might worsen estrogen dominance in girls who have already got it.
Q: What does “estrogen dominance” imply for menopausal girls?
A: Estrogen dominance refers to an extra of estrogen, notably relative to progesterone. A 2018 assessment revealed in Biomedicine & Pharmacotherapy hyperlinks extra estrogen, or estrogen-like exercise, to overexpression of estrogen receptors, tissue hurt, autoimmune ailments and cancers.8 Extra estrogen can also be thought to boost intracellular calcium ranges and impair mitochondrial perform.
Q: What can I do to keep away from estrogen dominance?
A: Life-style and dietary modifications are highly effective instruments. Keep away from processed meals, as they generally comprise seed oils wealthy in polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFs) like linoleic acid, which can have estrogen-like results. Additionally scale back your publicity to artificial estrogens like oral contraceptives and estrogen-mimicking chemical substances in on a regular basis merchandise, together with plastics. In the event you use a prescribed contraceptive or hormone remedy, discuss together with your physician earlier than making modifications.
Q: Are there any pure choices to assist steadiness my hormones throughout menopause?
A: Sure, there are. Past life-style and food regimen, think about discussing pure progesterone with a well being care supplier educated in hormone steadiness. Pure progesterone acts as an estrogen antagonist, which can assist to revive a more healthy progesterone-to-estrogen ratio throughout perimenopause and menopause.
This text is for informational functions solely and doesn’t represent medical recommendation. Seek the advice of a certified well being care supplier earlier than making modifications to your well being routine.

